When the Belly of a Whale Sounds Good

God said to Jonah, “Is your anger about the shrub a good thing?”

Jonah said, “Yes, my anger is good – even to the point of death!” – Jonah 4:9 (CEB)

The Jehovah’s Witnesses visit me monthly.  Last week, they brought me a flyer for their memorial gathering, and showed me a trailer for their movie Jonah. It looks pretty exciting.  The woman suggested that Jonah didn’t want to go to Nineveh because the Ninevites were so violent.

Maybe.  But it’s not his fear of their violence that sends him to Tarshish and eventually into the belly of a big fish.  It’s Jonah’s hate.

Jonah chooses his hate for the Ninevites over his love for God – even to the point of death.  The Bible talks a lot about being faithful even to death, but Jonah is unfaithful to the point of death.  He’s sort of a reverse martyr.  Sure he finally goes to Nineveh when the whale vomits him up on shore, but he doesn’t do it with a grateful and joyful heart.  He certainly doesn’t hope for God’s miracle of redemption.

Regardless how begrudging his word of accountability was to the Ninevites, they respond.  God has mercy on this pagan people who, in a moment of spiritual clarity, comprehend the gravity of their sin and the sovereignty of the One True God.  And Jonah is angry.

Even after he sees their acts of repentance, Jonah still holds out hopethat God will hate his enemy as much as he does.  In the part of the story that most of us haven’t read (unless you’ve watched the Veggie Tale), we witness the extent of Jonah’s hate and anger.  Jonah camps out in a spot overlooking the city hoping for God to rain down fire and brimstone.  But God doesn’t do this. And Jonah is angry.

Jonah’s hate for the Ninevites exceeds his love for God.  And this hate finally extends itself to anger with God.  Jonah is angry that God is compassionate and merciful to these underserving people whom Jonah doesn’t like.  And this isn’t just a difference of opinion – Jonah is angry about something at the core of God’s character.

I love the story of Jonah.  Not so much because of the big fish, but because of the humanity of this prophet and the story of God’s mercy.  Jesus said we are to love our enemies because God does. (Matthew 5:43-48). But for many of us, we would rather sell all our possessions and give our money to the poor before we would truly pray God’s redemptive mercy and love on those we hate.

This has hit home for me in 2016 and 2017.  I am heartsick and ashamed and angry and even fearful about the current state of our country.  I’ll be honest (and you might stop reading here):  I harbor hate in my heart for the President.  I don’t wish violence upon him.  But the policies that continue to endanger the most vulnerable and isolate the already marginalized make me physically ill.  I don’t think he’s a good person.  I believe my children are less safe today than they were 18 months ago. I’m not trying to convince you of anything.  I’m simply sharing my struggle because I don’t think I’ve ever hated anyone before.

The President isn’t my enemy or a Ninevite.  But sometimes the belly of a whale sounds good compared to sitting at the banquet table of God and sharing the Bread of Life and Cup of Salvation with someone I feel is doing evil upon people and doesn’t seem to care.

Thinking about Jonah this week has challenged me to examine myself and what I am willing to be faithful to – even to the point of death.  I am confronted again by God’s faithfulness and God’s sovereignty, and how I love these truths about God when they are in my favor.  But God doesn’t play favorites.

And so, as I sit overlooking Nineveh, I’m not angry with God for God’s generous and outrageous offer of mercy.  Because I know I, too, am in need of it.  Instead, I will continue to wrestle with my hate the same way Jacob wrestled with that angel on the way back to the Promised Land. And pray that I will be healed of my hate so that I can truly pray for God’s mercy.

Faithful and merciful God, I give thanks for who you are.  I am thankful that you forgive me and hold me close us and hold us close.  Illuminate my heart to see where I choose my hate over my love for you.  Teach me how to pray for someone I would rather hate than love.  And may my hope always be for the redemption of others for I desire to choose love above all things.  In the certainty of your faithfulness, mercy, and sovereignty, Amen.

But sometimes the belly of a whale sounds good compared to sitting at the banquet table of God and sharing the Bread of Life and Cup of Salvation with someone I feel is doing evil upon people and doesn’t seem to care. Click To Tweet


I hope you consider checking out my new book:

Prayers for the People: Scripturally Based Prayers for WorshipPrayers for the People is a collection of prayers for worship. These prayers offer the worshipping community fresh perspectives for praying the words of Scripture, using current language and references. Cross-referenced to the Revised Common Lectionary, pastors seeking to lead their people in prayer have found a relevant and beautiful source for worship planning.

Related posts

4 Thoughts to “When the Belly of a Whale Sounds Good”

  1. Muskego Glenn

    I’m sorry that you suffer so.

    1. lifeinthelabyrinth

      I don’t really see it as suffering on my part – although it is a spiritual struggle. If it was just my *suffering* I don’t think I’d have the struggle. It’s my bleeding heart that hurts at the suffering of others.

  2. Jeanne

    You totally nailed my current fears & hate for the direction our country is going. May I continue to love despite it all.

    1. lifeinthelabyrinth

      I really struggle with what is righteous anger vs. judgment. I’ve never felt this way about someone before, so it’s new ground for me spiritually.

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.