Exiled From the Nativity: Rebellion

They entered the house and saw the child with Mary his mother. – Matthew 2:11 (CEB)

As always, I finished decorating for Christmas early.  Even though I’m a big fan of Advent, I love decorating for Christmas.  Over the years, I’ve collected several nativity sets.  But there is always the question of what to do with the wise men.

I don’t want to just leave them in the box, but I also can’t bring myself to put them with the nativity.  Matthew 2 tells me that they don’t belong there.  The came to a house to see a child and from what happens with Herod, it was probably a year or two after Jesus’ brith.

The farthest point east in my house is our bedroom – and I don’t really want them there either.  So I find other obscure places to put them.

These wise men came all the way from Bethlehem, but in my house they have to stay up on the book shelf.


These wise men take shelter beneath the greens.

I don’t want the wise men at the nativity because it’s not “theologically correct.”  They came later in the story, and I rebel against their inclusion in Christmas.  But does anybody else notice or care that I’ve exiled the wise men?

Really, if I’m honest, it’s me indulging myself.  But I think it may represent something else a little deeper than that, too.  Is my forced exile of the wise men also my act of rebellion against the commercialization (and consumer-ization) of Christmas?   It’s not just the wise men that have no place at my nativity.

I didn’t even buy the wise men to go with this nativity.

Several years ago I stopped sending Christmas cards because it was one of the many things I “had” to do that was robbing me from being present during Advent (but I do enjoy the cards and pictures people send me – thank you!). I have since began doing a Christmas video of our year (which I enjoy – it will be coming about closer to New Year’s this year).  I also eschew all Christmas shopping.  This is not because I don’t like giving or wrapping gifts (or that I don’t like receiving them – again, thank you!).

It’s because I feel like I’m feeding the “winter holiday” machine.  The world has made Christmas all-inclusive.  Not by welcoming all to the nativity – except the wise men, of course – but by welcoming all into the shopping frenzy.

The world has made #Christmas all-inclusive. Not by welcoming all to the nativity – except the wise men, of course – but by welcoming all into the shopping frenzy. #Advent Click To Tweet

I refuse to buy things “to make it even” or because I “need” a gift for someone.  I apologize now to anyone who thinks I don’t care enough to buy a gift for them.  I actually care enough not to buy them something just because it’s on sale or a pre-packaged Christmas special.  Hopefully I show my care and generosity enough throughout the year.  I’m not a Grinch or cheap – it’s just that I can’t bring myself to buy-in to shopping and mandatory gift-giving in the last six weeks of the year.

So what about the wise men?  Should they be allowed to come out of exile, the pawns of my Christmas rebellion?  And is it really about them or is there a message here for me?


This is the part one of my reflections on excluding the wise men from my nativity.

Related posts

6 Thoughts to “Exiled From the Nativity: Rebellion”

  1. Muskego Glenn

    Now is that $10 net cost? What if it was on sale?

    1. We’re not Pharisees. 🙂

  2. Muskego Glenn

    My “favorite” exercise is the ceremonial exchanging of the same value gift cards. Makes the season just perfect!

    1. My extended family now does a $10 gift game. It’s fun to shop for and fun to play.

  3. […] may think I have a problem with magi, after I have exiled them from my nativity.  It’s true, I confess, that I have struggled with them being there these last five weeks, but I […]

  4. […] the wise men belong in the nativity?  If I set aside my rebellion, there is also a bit of theological snobbery here.  I claim scriptural authority in exiling the […]

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.